Southold Presbyterian Church Records

Introduction

This church was originally known as First Church of Southold and later became Southold Presbyterian Church. The below are copied from various published sources of the church records.

Transcript or Summary

Marriages and Baptisms during the Ministry of the Rev. William Throop, 1748-1756

Marriages
1749 June 22 Jona. Terry to Keturah Reeve
1749 Nov 23 John Gardner to Mary Reeve
1754 Aug 25 Elton Overton to Sarah Reeves

A Record of Marriages, Pastorate of John Storrs, 1763-1787
1768 Oct. 19 Robert Hemstead, Esq. and Mehitable Reeve both of this place.
1785 Jan 30 Abraham Reeve and Hannah Horton of ye Town.

Baptisms, Pastorate of John Storrs, 1763-1787
1765 Dec 29 Mary daughter of Joshua and Mary Reeves
1763 Aug 21 Abigael ye Daughter of Joshua Reeve & Mary his wife
1768 July 17 Kitturah, daughter of Joshua Reeve
1771 Oct 24 Elisha Reave & Martha Halliock both of ye (yt?) place
1772 Nov 22 Joshua, son of Joshua Reeve
1773 Aug 22 Gilbert, son of Martha Reeve
1774 Aug 17 Charlotte Augusta, daughter of Isac Reeve of Mattituck
1783 Dec 14 Joseph, son of Joshua Reve

A Record of Marriages...Joseph Hazzard
1811 Nov 19 Silas Reeve, Mattituck to Patty Handy, Southold
1815 Dec 4 At Aquebogue a Mr Brown to Miss Reeve
1816 Mar 4 Joseph Reeve to Widdow Abigail Horton
1818 Aug 20 Henry Reeve to Mary Ann Loper both of Shelter Island

1812 2 Aug. Orin Reeves to Miss Betsey Tuthill, both of Southold.

1859 10 Sep John W. Reeves, of Baiting Hollow, L. I., to Deborah Sawyer. Wits: James Sawyer, Hannah M. Whitaker
1860 11 Nov Horace P. Tillinghast to Jane A. Reeve. Wits: Charles Reeve and wife, not named

Commentary

It may be that the marriage date of Orin was misread as 1812 with the original as 1832 as this is the first in another volume which has further entries starting in 1834.

Source

FamilySearch - New York Genealogical and Biographical Record Vol. 64, pp. 217, 322
FamilySearch - New York Genealogical and Biographical Record Vol. 65, pp. 47, 152, 261, 339
FamilySearch - New York Genealogical and Biographical Record Vol. 66, pp. 261-269
With Additions from:
FamilySearch - Records of the First Church in Southold, 1747-1832

Corrections from U.S., Presbyterian Church Records, 1701-1970 (Ancestry)